The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson
Wednesday, December 31st, 2008
This book really missed the mark for me. I was very excited to get my hands on it and felt like it had great promise to make it to my “favorites” list. The thought of a Gothic, modern romantic tragedy really attracted me despite the inherent heavy religious emphasis. The format was well done (switching from the heroine’s historic story telling to main character’s modern narration) but that is where the success ended. The text was not nearly as dramatic as I had hoped for given my normal swooning feeling for the historic German-Gothic emphasis. I also think it is important to note that the narrator was far too narcissistic; to the point of deemphasizing the connection between two people in a love story. One comical highlight, in my opinion, is the numerous references made the narrator’s penis; it felt like almost obligatory on the part of the author – a man writing a love story – how could the emphasis not be on his penis, or in the case the lack of.
In all I wouldn’t tell others to not read this book, but I would tell them to not get their hopes up. The format was well done and the historical context is interesting and likely accurate to some degree. The story lacks depth and felt a bit anti climatic for me, but it worked as a fast read to get me through to the next novel.


